I See Every Lie but His

GoodNovel Completed

I have the ability to see a number floating above everyone's head. It tells me how many times that person has lied to me. Back in elementary school, my desk mate steals my eraser and denies it. The number above his head changes to one. When my parents divorce, Dad promises he'll be back soon, and the number changes to two. Later, when Mom falls seriously ill, she holds my hand from her hospital bed and tells me she's only going to sleep for a little while. The number changes to three. I've known since childhood that everyone has secrets and everyone lies, so I learn to keep my guard up and never trust anyone too easily. That is, until I meet Ethan Callahan. We've been together for five years, and the number above his head has never once changed. It has always remained at zero. When he tells me he's going on a business trip, it stays at zero. When he tells me he loves me, it's still zero. Even when he promises to marry me once things settle down, I look at that zero and keep waiting. For five whole years, I believe him. I'm convinced Ethan will never lie to me, but everything changes on my 28th birthday. Just as I'm making my third wish, Ethan gives me an apologetic look. "I'm sorry, Jennifer. Something's come up with a project, and I need to head back to the office." Feeling bad about how hard he's been working, I'm about to tell him that it's okay when the number above his head, which hasn't changed in five years, suddenly flickers. Then, before my eyes, the zero turns into a one. Ethan has lied to me. I look at him, trying to gauge his reaction, before asking, "Are you really going to a meeting?" Without even looking up, he grabs his jacket and heads for the door. "Don't overthink it. When have I ever lied to you?" The front door slams shut, leaving me alone with the candles still burning on my birthday cake. But my third wish—that Ethan will never lie to me—has just become impossible.

Chapters (1)

Chapter 1

I have the ability to see a number floating above everyone's head. It tells me how many times that person has lied to me. Back in elementary school, my desk mate steals my eraser and denies it. The number above his head changes to one. When my parents divorce, Dad promises he'll be back soon, and the number changes to two. Later, when Mom falls seriously ill, she holds my hand from her hospital bed and tells me she's only going to sleep for a little while. The number changes to three. I've known since childhood that everyone has secrets and everyone lies, so I learn to keep my guard up and never trust anyone too easily. That is, until I meet Ethan Callahan. We've been together for five years, and the number above his head has never once changed. It has always remained at zero. When he tells me he's going on a business trip, it stays at zero. When he tells me he loves me, it's still zero. Even when he promises to marry me once things settle down, I look at that zero and keep waiting. For five whole years, I believe him. I'm convinced Ethan will never lie to me, but everything changes on my 28th birthday. Just as I'm making my third wish, Ethan gives me an apologetic look. "I'm sorry, Jennifer. Something's come up with a project, and I need to head back to the office." Feeling bad about how hard he's been working, I'm about to tell him that it's okay when the number above his head, which hasn't changed in five years, suddenly flickers. Then, before my eyes, the zero turns into a one. Ethan has lied to me. I look at him, trying to gauge his reaction, before asking, "Are you really going to a meeting?" Without even looking up, he grabs his jacket and heads for the door. "Don't overthink it. When have I ever lied to you?" The front door slams shut, leaving me alone with the candles still burning on my birthday cake. But my third wish—that Ethan will never lie to me—has just become impossible. Chapter 1 Melted candle wax dripped onto the frosting, and suddenly, I lost my appetite just looking at the cake. That glowing number one kept flashing before my eyes. I almost wished I'd imagined it, or that somehow, it was nothing more than a harmless lie. But the next second, the digital tablet on the table lit up, revealing Ethan Callahan's WhatsApp chat, which was still open. There were two pinned conversations. One was mine, and the other was marked with a sun emoji. It belonged to Vivian Hartley, Ethan's assistant. Just three minutes earlier, she'd sent him a message, "Drive safe. I'll be waiting for you." Ten minutes before that, when Ethan told me he'd been called away for an unexpected meeting, Vivian had been complaining to him. "Mr. Callahan, my cramps are killing me." Ethan had replied almost immediately, "I'm on my way." In the 30 seconds I'd spent with my eyes closed, making a wish, he'd already been on his way to lie to me for another woman. My hands trembled as I scrolled through their chat history, reading message after message. Over the past three months, Vivian had sent him countless pictures and voice messages. Even when all she sent was a sticker, Ethan would quote it and take the time to reply. Yet whenever I shared a playlist of songs I liked, he'd frown and complain that it was too noisy. When I sent him little snippets of my daily life, he'd give me a cold look and dismiss them as meaningless. There were no explicit messages or suggestive exchanges between them. On the surface, their conversations seemed perfectly ordinary, as though neither of them had crossed any obvious lines. But Vivian had already become someone special to Ethan. Special enough that, for her sake, he'd told me his first lie in five years. I closed the chat and opened the location-tracking app. Ethan's location showed him stopped outside a dessert shop. I'd been craving the chocolate tiramisu from that shop for ages, but Ethan always insisted it was too far away. Instead of making the trip, he'd just transfer me some money and tell me to order it for delivery. I'd even explained that the shop didn't offer delivery, but he'd still never once been willing to take me there. Yet now, he'd been sitting outside the shop for nearly two hours. Then a bank notification popped up, showing a payment of 68 dollars. Ethan had spent two hours waiting in line just to cheer Vivian up. He hadn't complained about the distance or the long wait, all because Vivian had mentioned something from that shop two weeks ago, and he'd remembered. The red location marker disappeared, perhaps because he'd lost his signal. But I already knew where Ethan would end up: at Vivian's apartment. I sat on the couch all night, and Ethan didn't come home until dawn. He hung up his coat, then paused in surprise when he saw me. "You haven't slept?" "I was waiting for you," I replied. "Why? Didn't I tell you I had a meeting?" Ethan walked over and placed a box of tiramisu on the table. "You said you wanted to try the tiramisu from this place. I passed by the shop on my way home, so I picked some up for you." I glanced at the number above his head. It had changed to two. This was his second lie, and once again, it was because of Vivian. "Ethan, I wanted the chocolate flavor, not mango." He irritably tugged at his tie. "What's the difference? Jennifer, I've been working all night. I'm exhausted. Can you stop making a fuss?" I said nothing. Ethan turned and headed back into the bedroom, closing the door behind him. I picked up the box of mango tiramisu and noticed a small sticker in the bottom-right corner with a single word printed on it: "Free." So it was a leftover freebie Vivian hadn't finished. Ethan had simply passed it along to me, as though he were getting rid of something he didn't want. I threw the tiramisu into the garbage. Then I walked toward the master bedroom, where I could hear Ethan speaking in a gentle voice. "Does it still hurt? I'll stay with you. Get some sleep." I stood outside the door, feeling the warmth drain from my body. I'd spent the entire night waiting for him, yet he hadn't once asked if I was okay or shown the slightest concern. All I'd gotten in return was an accusation that I was making a fuss. He'd saved all his tenderness for another woman. I took out my phone and looked at the transfer request my supervisor had sent me two days earlier. It was an application for a transfer to Havenport. After a moment's hesitation, I finally tapped "Confirm." I didn't want to wait until his lies piled up and the pain became unbearable before finally choosing to walk away. Chapter 2 I slept on the couch until evening. When I woke up, I found a light blanket draped over me. A plane ticket sat on the table, beside a half-empty glass of water. Ethan sat down next to me, his voice unusually gentle. "You haven't been yourself lately, so I bought you a ticket to Willowmere. Take a little trip and clear your head." I looked down at the ticket in my hand. "What about you?" Ethan froze for a moment before discreetly slipping two other tickets behind his back. "I have an overseas project that requires me to handle things in person. I can't go with you." The number above his head changed to three. Ethan had lied to me again. I didn't call him out on it. I simply nodded, and he visibly relaxed. As soon as I heard the shower running, I slipped into the study and retrieved the two tickets Ethan had hidden in the desk drawer. One was for Ethan, and the other was for Vivian. Their departure date was three days away, and their destination was Northwood. I stared at the tickets for a long time. The snow in Northwood was tied to the first promise Ethan had ever made me, five years ago. It had been our first year together, and I had accompanied him to South City to build a life from scratch. I was from the north, and it was also the first time I'd gone an entire year without seeing snow. Ethan had noticed how down I'd been throughout that winter. Holding me in his arms, he'd made me a promise. "One day, I'll take you somewhere in the world where we can see the most romantic snowfall." "Northwood?" I asked. "Deal. Northwood it is!" Eventually, Ethan's career took off, and I'd asked him countless times when we'd finally take that trip. But he always gave me the same excuses—he didn't have time, he was too busy, and Northwood wasn't going anywhere. And he was right. Northwood wasn't going anywhere. But I hadn't seen snow in five years either. And now, the person he'd chosen to fulfill that promise with was someone else. Ethan came out of the bathroom and walked into the study, where I was still holding the two tickets. He strode over and snatched them from my hands, his voice sharp with anger. "Why were you going through my things?" he demanded. "You're going to Northwood?" He quickly took the tickets and put them away. "Yes. It's for a project in Northwood." I fell silent for a moment before asking, "Are you going with Vivian?" Ethan irritably ran a hand through his hair. "What's wrong with that? Vivian is my assistant. Isn't it perfectly normal for me to bring her along?" I let out a bitter laugh. "Ethan, I want to go to Northwood too. I've been asking you for five years." He went quiet for a moment, then picked up the Willowmere ticket I'd left on the table and pressed it back into my hand. "Let's go to Willowmere this year. I'll take you to Northwood next time." The number above his head changed again. This time, it was four. Another "next time". Another promise that would never be kept. I could no longer tell which of Ethan's words were true and which were lies. One by one, every promise he'd made to me had fallen through. I tried to hold on to what little patience I had left, but in the end, I couldn't stop myself from asking, "Ethan, you promised you'd marry me. Does that promise still stand?" His hand froze mid-motion as he dried his hair. "Why are you bringing this up all of a sudden? Jennifer, are you really that desperate to get married?" His words struck me like a blow, leaving my head spinning. My lips moved, but I couldn't hear what I was saying. I couldn't even remember how I managed to walk out of the study. All I knew was that by the time I reached the bedroom, the Willowmere ticket in my hand had been crumpled into a ball. On my phone screen was a flight to Havenport, booked for three days from now. Chapter 3 Early the next morning, after packing my things, I decided to make one last visit to the house Ethan and I had planned to call home after we got married. If I could no longer count on him to keep his promise to marry me, then there was no reason for me to keep thinking of that house as my home. When I reached the front door, I froze, wondering if I'd come to the wrong address. Two potted plants sat beside the door, and two pairs of matching slippers were neatly arranged on the shoe rack. The men's pair was a US size 9, the same size Ethan wore. The women's pair was a US size 5, but I wore a size 6 I raised my hand and knocked twice. The sound echoed through the hallway. I couldn't tell whether it was the sound of my knuckles against the door or my own heart pounding in my chest. The door opened, revealing Vivian. The moment she saw me, all the color drained from her face. "Ms. Anderson, what brings you here?" Her question struck me as almost laughable. This was supposed to be the home Ethan and I would share after getting married, yet here she was, standing in the doorway like the lady of the house, questioning why I'd come. "This is my marital home." Vivian opened and closed her mouth, but no words came out. I stepped inside. The last time I'd been here, the place had been nothing more than an unfinished shell. Ethan had promised that once things settled down at work, he'd renovate it into the cozy little home I'd always dreamed of. I believed him. For months, I'd made countless trips to home improvement stores, picking out paint colors and choosing furniture, carefully planning every last detail. I'd poured so much time and effort into making that dream a reality. Now, the house had finally taken shape, but it had become someone else's home. Vivian tapped away at her phone. A second later, my phone rang. Ethan was calling. "Don't give Vivian a hard time. I'm on my way. Don't you dare hurt her." His voice was tight with worry. He was warning me not to bother Vivian, as if I were the intruder who'd barged into someone else's home. Ethan arrived in no time. Seeing him rush in, looking as though he'd come straight from somewhere else, made my heart ache. The moment he stepped inside, he went straight to Vivian and looked her over from head to toe. "Are you okay? Did she do anything to you?" Only after confirming that Vivian was unharmed did he turn to me, frowning. "What are you doing here?" It was the same question Vivian had asked me. Apparently, Ethan also thought I had no business being there. "This is our marital home. Am I not allowed to come here?" Ethan sighed. "That's not what I meant." "Ethan, why is she living here?" I demanded. He fell silent for a moment before answering. "Vivian got kicked out by her landlord and had nowhere else to go. She's just staying here temporarily. She won't be here long, so I didn't think there was any need to tell you." The number above Ethan's head changed again. This time, it became six. He'd claimed Vivian was only staying temporarily, but that had turned out to be a lie. And his claim that she wouldn't be here for long? That was another lie. I let out a cold laugh. "Ethan, she makes 20 thousand dollars a month working at Callahan Corp. Does she really have nowhere else to go, or does she just enjoy taking things that belong to other people?" Vivian's eyes immediately reddened as she stepped in front of Ethan. "Ms. Anderson, I know you don't like me. I'll move out if that's what you want. But please, don't take it out on Mr. Callahan!" I had no intention of wasting another word on her. Instead, I pulled out my phone to call the police, but Ethan stopped me. "What are you doing?" "Calling the police. She's trespassing." Ethan frowned. "Calling the police won't help you." I stared at him in disbelief, struggling to process what he'd just said. Just then, the elevator doors behind me opened, and a property management representative walked over. "Ms. Hartley, Mr. Callahan, is everything okay?" He then turned to me. "Ma'am, Ms. Hartley and Mr. Callahan are the legal owners of this property." As if anticipating that I wouldn't believe him, he pulled up a photo of the property deed on his phone and showed it to me. Ethan's name was listed first, followed by Vivian's. I stood there, my mind completely blank, struggling to process what I'd just heard. Slowly, I turned to Ethan, but he wouldn't meet my eyes. When I finally managed to speak, my voice was so broken that I could barely get the words out. "Ethan… you put her name on the deed to our marital home?" "Vivian has had a hard time making it on her own in a big city. I just wanted to help her out and give her somewhere she could feel secure." My voice rose until I was practically screaming. "She's having a hard time making it on her own? Was it easy for my mother to scrape together the 200 thousand dollars for your down payment?" He said nothing. I stared at him, unable to look away. When we bought this house, we were 200 thousand dollars short of what we needed. My mother had emptied the savings she'd spent half her life building up just to make up the difference. The day Ethan received the property deed, he'd knelt in front of my mother, tears in his eyes, and sworn, "From now on, no matter what happens, this will always be Jennifer's home." And now, another woman was living in my home, with her name, not mine, on the property deed. The number above Ethan's head changed again. This time, it became seven. It took me a moment to understand what that meant. A promise you never intended to keep was just another lie, wasn't it? Seeing that I'd fallen silent, Ethan let out a sigh. "Just go home for now. You're too emotional right now. You'll only scare Vivian." The two security guards who'd accompanied the property management representative stepped forward. One of them gave me a sympathetic look. "Ma'am, please don't make this difficult for us." I suddenly fell silent. I didn't argue or make a scene. I simply stepped into the elevator. Just before the doors closed, I caught one last glimpse of Ethan gently wiping away Vivian's tears with his thumb. Chapter 4 Three days later, Ethan left before sunrise. He headed to the airport to catch a flight to Northwood, where he would watch the snowfall with Vivian—the very snowfall I'd waited five years to see with him. After packing my things, I opened the hidden compartment at the back of my bedroom drawer one last time. Inside, I'd kept a discontinued camera model. It contained photographs my mother had taken before she passed away, the last precious memories she'd left me. But the moment I pulled open the compartment, I froze. The camera was gone. All that remained was a memory card. I'd always kept the camera somewhere safe and rarely took it out. Besides me, Ethan was the only other person who knew where I'd hidden it. Thinking I might have remembered the wrong place, I searched every drawer and turned the entire room upside down. But the camera was nowhere to be found. With trembling hands, I picked up my phone and started a video call with Ethan. The moment he answered, I spotted Vivian in the background, happily snapping pictures with my camera in her hands. She turned around, looking delighted. "Mr. Callahan, the pictures from this camera look amazing! Good thing you brought it along. Otherwise, we would've missed so many great photo opportunities!" Ethan smiled at her before turning back to the screen, his voice indifferent. "What is it?" My eyes were already red as I confronted him. "Ethan, did you take my camera and give it to her?" He didn't seem to think he'd done anything wrong. "Your camera takes great pictures, so I brought it along. Vivian likes photography." "Why didn't you ask me first?" I demanded. He frowned. "Vivian is only borrowing it. She'll return it when we get back. Don't be so petty." My voice rose as I fought the urge to reach through the screen and snatch the camera back. "Ethan, that camera belonged to my mother!" He irritably ran a hand through his hair, his expression turning cold. "Jennifer Anderson, it's just a camera. What, are we not allowed to use something just because the person who owned it is dead?" I froze. Ethan seemed to realize he'd gone too far. A flicker of regret crossed his eyes, but he made no attempt to explain himself. He simply fell silent. People continued moving back and forth behind him, while Vivian remained absorbed in taking pictures, completely oblivious to the people around her. Suddenly, a child came rushing past and bumped into her. Startled, Vivian lost her grip on the camera, sending it crashing to the ground. She let out a cry and stumbled backward, hitting the railing. Ethan immediately rushed over, stepping right on the shattered camera lens as he pulled Vivian into his arms. The video call was still connected, and my screen now showed nothing but broken glass scattered across the ground. My breath caught as a chill ran through my entire body. That camera model had been discontinued for years, and there wasn't another compatible lens to be found anywhere. Ethan's voice softened. "Vivian, are you okay? Did you get hurt?" "Mr. Callahan, I think I scraped my knee, but I'm fine. You should check Ms. Anderson's camera first. Otherwise, she'll be upset if it's damaged." Only then did Ethan notice the broken pieces scattered across the ground. He didn't even bother picking them up. Instead, he scooped Vivian into his arms and turned back toward the camera so his face filled the screen again. Vivian's eyes grew misty as she nestled against him. "It's just a camera. Let me take you to get your injury checked first." The camera he so casually dismissed as just another camera was the last precious thing my mother had left me. I shouted into the screen, my voice nearly frantic. "Ethan! My camera is broken!" He sighed impatiently. "So what? Vivian didn't break it on purpose." He continued, "The camera is an inanimate object, but Vivian is a living person. I can't just leave her alone to pick up a pile of broken pieces that can't even be put back together. "I'll buy you a new one when we get back. Jennifer, stop being unreasonable." With that, he ended the video call. The dark screen of my phone reflected my lonely face. I wanted to cry, but I couldn't even shed a tear anymore. An overwhelming sense of helplessness washed over me. I don't know how long I sat there before I finally got to my feet, grabbed my suitcase, and headed for the airport. Seven lies. One marital home. One broken camera. The distance between Ethan and me had grown to thousands upon thousands of miles. There was no going back.

More GoodNovel Novels