Chapter 1
Until I turned eighteen, I always thought my parents respected my choices. When it came to extracurricular classes, they let me choose for myself.
It was only after I chose art that my father, Dylan Sutton, asked, "What kind of job can you get with that?"
When it was time to choose between the humanities and science tracks, they let me decide for myself, too.
It was only after I chose humanities that my mother, Alana Sutton, stopped speaking to me for three days.
When it came to choosing a college, they still left the decision up to me, but on the night I had to submit my applications, my dad sat behind me.
Every time I selected a school, he asked the same question: "Are you sure?"
By the fifth time, I had deleted the university I wanted to attend most.
My mom finally smiled. "See? Your dad and I never force you to do anything."
In the end, I followed their wishes and majored in something I had absolutely no interest in.
The year I graduated, I came home with a job offer from a company in another city.
My dad set the offer letter on the table. "You're an adult now. Of course we'll respect whatever you decide."
My mom nodded. "It's entirely up to you whether you go or stay."
I had just begun to breathe a sigh of relief when she placed Grandma's medical report beside the offer letter.
"It's just that... who knows how many more years we'll have Grandma with us?"
That night, I turned down the job.
A year later, I failed the civil service exam.
After two drinks, my dad announced to a table full of relatives, "Young people just can't afford to be so stubborn. We told her to take that job out of town back then, but she was the one who absolutely refused."
I looked up.
And he didn't even realize that this time, I remembered everything perfectly.
Chapter 1
The moment my father, Dylan Sutton, said it, Aunt Elaine was reaching for a piece of fish.
She paused, then laughed. "See? I told you. Young people never know what they want. In the end, it's always the parents who get blamed."
I looked at Dad. "It wasn't that I didn't want to go back then."
He set down his glass. "Did you or did you not click 'Send' on that rejection email yourself?"
"Mom used Grandma's medical report—"
"Did I hold a knife to your throat?"
Mom jumped in before I could finish. "I only told you Grandma wasn't doing well. If you really wanted to go, who could've stopped you?"
Everyone at the table was looking at me.
For a moment, I was back in the living room the night I had to fill out my college applications.
Dad hadn't said I wasn't allowed to choose. He'd simply sat behind me, asking over and over, "Are you sure?"
Mom hadn't told me not to go. She'd just refused to speak to me for three days.
They always left the door open. It was just that disappointment, tears, icy silence, and accusations of selfishness were waiting right outside it.
And whenever I finally gave in and came back, they'd smile and say, "See? We never forced you."
Dad tapped the edge of the table. "You couldn't pass the civil service exam, so I've signed you up for a prep course starting next week. It cost $1,300. No more wasting time on nonsense."
"I'm not going."
His eyebrows immediately drew together.
But Mom put a hand on his arm. "If she doesn't want to go, let her be. She's twenty-four. We respect her choices."
As everyone was getting ready to leave, Aunt Elaine patted my shoulder. "Your parents are awfully open-minded. If my kid refused a $1,300 course after I'd paid for it, I'd have given them an earful."
Mom smiled apologetically. "She has her own ideas. We can only make suggestions."
Then she posted a screenshot of the course payment in the family group chat.
Someone replied almost immediately: "Being a parent really isn't easy."
I stared at the message.
They didn't need to order me around.
All they had to do was make sure everyone saw how much they had sacrificed. Then, if I still refused to obey, I'd naturally become the ungrateful, unreasonable daughter.
The next morning, I discovered that my ID card, college diploma, and degree certificate were missing.
In the master bedroom, Dad was placing my ID card on the scanner.
"What are you doing with my documents?"
"Registering you for the course."
"I told you I'm not going."
"Registering you doesn't mean I'm forcing you to attend. I'm just keeping the option open."
I reached for the folder.
He moved it behind his back. "I'll hold on to these for now. You've been distracted lately. You keep losing things."
"Give them back."
He finally looked up. "Yvette, I've paid your tuition, found your teachers, handled all the paperwork. When have I ever failed to take care of you? And now you're calling my good intentions controlling?"
Mom leaned against the doorway. "Your father stayed up until one last night researching the course. If you don't want to take the exam, then don't. But why hurt his feelings over a few documents?"
Somehow, my simple request to have my own things returned had become another example of how unreasonable I was.
That afternoon, the company in another city—the one I'd previously turned down—sent me a message.
Someone in the position I'd been offered had suddenly resigned. If I was still interested, I could start in ten days.
I stared at the screen for a long time.
[I'm interested.]
That evening, Dad stacked the course textbooks on my desk. My college poster design was buried underneath them.
"Class starts at nine tomorrow. Whether you go or not is up to you."
I said nothing.
After they went to bed, I pressed my spare key into a bar of soap, making sure every ridge and groove left a clear impression.
I always thought that if I explained myself well enough, they would eventually understand that I had the right to make my own decisions. I didn't want to explain anymore.
Just before bed, Dad knocked and came into my room again. He placed the course receipt on top of the textbooks. "The money's already been paid. There's no refund."
I looked at the figure: $1,300. "So you paid first, and now I'm supposed to make my own decision?"
He frowned. "Did I drag you there by force?"
Mom sighed from the doorway. "Do you have any idea how little your father earns in a month? Don't throw away money just to prove a point."
The next morning, the course began. I went to my shift at the stationery store as usual.
The $1,300 really had gone to waste. It hurt so much that I didn't dare check my bank balance for the entire day.
But for the first time, I didn't turn around halfway there just because I'd disappointed them.
Chapter 2
I worked evening shifts at a stationery store in the mall. The pay wasn't great, but it left my days free to prepare the paperwork for my new job in another city.
I'd barely changed into my uniform when my manager, Scott Foster, poked his head out from behind the register.
"Yvette? What are you doing here?"
"I have a shift today."
He looked confused. Then he reached under the counter and pulled out a red plastic bag. "Didn't your mom quit for you yesterday?"
Inside were four shiny red apples.
Scott looked uncomfortable. "She said you needed to focus on preparing for the civil service exam. She also said you were too shy to tell me yourself, so I shouldn't stand in the way of your future. She even settled your uniform deposit."
I stood there, my fingertips slowly turning cold.
Mom really had asked me the name of the store yesterday. She had even smiled and said, "Maybe I'll come by one day and see where you work."
So she hadn't wanted to visit. She wanted to put an end to my job.
"I didn't quit."
Scott scratched his head. "I've already given your shifts to someone else. Your mom sounded so certain. I thought you'd discussed it."
He hesitated, then handed me his phone.
Mom had even sent him a voice message the day before.
"If she comes back, please don't give in. Young people think they can make their own decisions just because they've had a little taste of hardship. The truth is, she hasn't even figured out what she wants from life."
At the end, she had actually laughed. "Please, just do a favor for a mother who's worried about her daughter."
I handed the phone back.
When I was little, she had withdrawn me from art classes without asking. She also brought a bag of fruit to apologize to the teacher. She was always polite and gracious.
"I'm so sorry. My daughter doesn't know any better. I hope she hasn't caused you too much trouble."
And afterward, everyone would tell me how lucky I was to have a mother like her.
As it happened, someone had called in sick. I changed back into my uniform and covered their shift for two hours.
After work, I didn't leave through the mall's main entrance. Carrying two shirts, a pair of sneakers, and the charging cable for my drawing tablet, I took the staff exit to the shipping counter.
The box weighed five pounds.
"Moving?" the courier asked.
I paused. "Something like that."
It turned out that leaving the home where I'd lived for twenty-four years began with a box weighing just five pounds.
That evening, meatloaf was waiting on the dinner table.
Mom put a piece in my bowl. "I quit your part-time job for you. Standing for five hours a day is exhausting. Your feet were swollen when you got home. It breaks my heart to see you like that."
"Why didn't you ask me first?"
"Would you have listened if I had?" She smiled and pushed the plate closer. "You're still young. You don't understand what's important yet. Once you pass the exam, you'll thank me."
I moved the piece of meatloaf back onto the serving plate. "I'm going to talk to my manager tomorrow and explain what happened."
Dad looked up from behind his phone. "You call earning a little over $1500 a month a real job?"
"It's money I earned myself."
"And what does that prove? That we can't afford to support you?" Mom sighed. "We're not saying you can't work. Once you've passed the exam, you can find whatever job you want."
There it was again.
Someday.
When I was little, they said I could draw once I started high school. In high school, it was after the college entrance exams. In college, it was after graduation, once I had a stable job.
The things I loved were always put away for some distant "someday".
That night, I hid in the bathroom and signed the electronic lease for an apartment in the other city.
After paying the deposit, I had only $270 left in my bank account.
I stared at the balance for a long time.
I was afraid the money wouldn't last and that I wouldn't be good enough at the job. I was worried I would get sick in a strange city with no one to look after me.
But this fear was different from the fear I had known before.
Before, they had stood over me, asking, "Are you sure?"
Now, I was asking myself.
Even if I got the answer wrong, at least it would be my answer.
Chapter 3
I booked a train ticket for nine days later.
After paying, I wrapped my two favorite art books in old newspaper, ready to ship them the next day.
The tape ripped with a loud snap.
I stopped and listened. There was no sound outside.
Just as I began to relax, Mom knocked on my door. "Don't go to the store tomorrow. Your father has arranged a medical checkup for the civil service exam."
I quickly turned off my screen. "Okay."
It was the first time I'd lied to her. Strangely, I didn't feel guilty at all. I simply started wondering what else I could fit into the next box.
Once the ticket was booked, I began moving things out a little at a time—my bank cards, spare clothes, my old drawing tablet, and the illustrations I'd kept from college.
I couldn't risk dragging a suitcase out of the house, so I locked everything in the stationery store's staff locker.
On the evening of the eighth day, I used the duplicate key I'd had made to open the drawer in the living room. My ID card and diploma were inside.
I had barely tucked the folder against my chest when the lights snapped on behind me.
Dad stood in the bedroom doorway. "What are you doing?"
His eyes landed on the folder. His expression darkened. "Give it to me."
"It's mine."
"I said, give it to me."
I stepped back.
Mom came out too. Her eyes fell on the half-empty canvas bag beside the entrance. "Are you still planning to leave?"
I didn't answer.
Dad lunged forward and grabbed the strap of my bag.
I held on for dear life. "Let go."
"So now you're stealing from us?"
"I'm taking my own documents. How is that stealing?"
"Anything kept in this house belongs to the family!" He yanked hard.
The strap snapped. My documents scattered across the floor, and my ID card slid beneath the shoe cabinet.
I bent down to retrieve it.
Dad grabbed my arm from behind and jerked me backward.
My foot missed the step, and I fell down the two steps at the entrance. My right hand hit the tile first.
For a split second, everything went white. Then pain drove through my wrist like a red-hot nail. I curled up on the floor. My wrist began swelling almost immediately.
Mom's face went pale. "Dylan! What are you doing? You can't just put your hands on her!"
Dad was breathing hard. "I didn't push her. She lost her balance while trying to snatch her things."
At the hospital, the X-ray showed a hairline fracture in my right wrist. The doctor asked how I'd fallen.
Mom answered before I could, "She'd been irritable lately, arguing with us. She must have missed a step."
The doctor glanced at me.
Dad sat beside us, still pinning the document folder beneath his leg.
I said nothing.
After I got home, the pain turned even the smallest tasks into struggles. I couldn't tie my hair, open a medicine bottle, or even secure a plastic bag over my cast before showering.
The next morning, Mom stood behind me and brushed my hair. "See? You can't even tie your own hair. How are you supposed to manage all the way out there by yourself?"
"My wrist will heal."
"And what about when you get sick? Or someone scams you? Who will you turn to when your family isn't around?"
At noon, I tried washing clothes with one hand and knocked the entire basin of water onto the floor.
Mom rushed in. She didn't scold me. She simply crouched down and started cleaning up. "Stop. I'll do it."
She washed the clothes, wrung them out, and hung them up to dry.
I stood there, feeling worse than I would have if she'd yelled at me.
She really did love me. She also genuinely believed that loving me meant taking over everything I couldn't do perfectly on my own.
My train ticket was refunded that same day. Mom had used my fingerprint to unlock my phone while I was asleep.
The refund notification came through while I was hanging socks on the balcony.
"Who told you to cancel it?"
Dad blocked the doorway. "Look at your hand! Where do you think you're going? What job could possibly be more important than your health?"
I stared at him for a few seconds, then said nothing.
That night, I hid in the bathroom and typed out an explanation to HR with my left hand, one letter at a time.
Half an hour later, they replied: "We can hold the position for you until the tenth of next month. Focus on recovering first."
I read the message three times.
Then I deleted the chat, copied the number onto a piece of paper, folded it, and slipped it inside my civil service exam study guide.
From outside the door, Mom called, "Have you taken your medicine?"
I closed the book. "Yes."
This time, I didn't even tell Grandma.
Chapter 4
Over the next month, I suddenly became very obedient.
I attended the prep course, did the practice questions, and came home on time.
Every day, my father would check my progress, and I would show it to him without hesitation.
Mom finally relaxed. She even started telling relatives in the family group chat, "She's finally come around. Young people need to hit a wall once in a while before they learn."
They had no idea that my delayed job offer, new train ticket, and rental agreement were all tucked inside my exam prep book.
The day before my cast was due to come off, I went to visit my grandmother, Patsy Sutton. She was sitting on the balcony trimming green beans when her left hand suddenly stopped.
"My hand's gone numb. Same old problem." She shook it out and quickly went back to work.
I didn't think much of it. I just asked her about the medical report from the previous year.
Grandma looked confused for a long moment. "What was so serious about it? The doctor only told me to cut back on sweets. Your mother made such a fuss over nothing. I even told her not to jinx things."
Standing on the balcony, I felt my fingers slowly turn cold. So even the claim that Grandma might only have a few more years left had been an answer Mom had made up for me.
Grandma read my expression. She didn't try to make excuses for Mom. She simply snapped another green bean in half.
"If you want to go, then go."
I didn't say anything.
"And if it doesn't work out, you can come home." She looked up at me. "You only get one life. You ought to have a few things you chose for yourself, even if they turn out to be mistakes."
Before I left that day, she dug a small metal tin out of her cabinet. Inside were drawings I'd made as a child—a blue roof, a big window.
On the back was something she'd written years ago: "Yvette drew this. Do not throw it away."
"Your mother thought they took up too much space, so I kept them for you."
I held the tin against my chest. For the first time, I felt that the things I'd loved as a child didn't need to prove they were useful to deserve a place in my life.
Three days later, early in the morning, I wheeled my suitcase to the door.
Dad was sitting in the living room while Mom stood by the kitchen entrance.
My phone was on the table.
Dad pushed a printed sheet of paper toward me.
"Your notice of voluntary withdrawal from the position has been received. The position is no longer available."
I stared at the words "voluntary withdrawal".
"Who sent this?"
"I did." Dad's voice was calm. "I cut off a path that wasn't right for you."
Mom immediately chimed in, "I called HR last night too. Your hand hasn't even healed. What could you possibly do there? After I explained the situation, they agreed it wasn't suitable either."
"Give me my phone."
Dad put his palm over it. "What's the point? They've already filled the position."
"Give it to me." I reached for it.
He instinctively shoved me aside. My recently uncast right wrist slammed into the corner of the table.
Pain exploded through it. My vision went black, and my knees hit the floor.
When my phone fell beside me, I tried to reach for it. The moment I put weight on my right hand, my entire arm gave way. My forehead struck the edge of the table.
Mom screamed and rushed over to hold me. "Don't move! How did you manage to hurt yourself again?"
At the hospital, the follow-up examination showed that the bone hadn't broken again, but I'd suffered a second soft-tissue injury. The doctor told me to rest for at least another three weeks.
When we got home, Mom made pasta, and Dad renewed my enrollment for the next stage of the prep course. They were even gentler with me than before.
Mom pushed the bowl toward me. "There'll be other jobs. Get your hand better first, then prepare for the provincial civil service exam."
I said nothing.
She stroked my hair. "Don't be so stubborn this time, okay?"
I nodded.
She visibly relaxed.
The door closed. At last, the room was quiet.
My unfinished illustrations were still on the desk. I picked up a pencil.
The moment I tried to apply pressure with my right hand, the tip trembled across the paper, leaving a crooked black line.
I loosened my grip and tried again. The pencil slipped from my fingers and clattered to the floor. It rolled twice before stopping against the wall.
I bent down to pick it up. The moment my fingertips touched the pencil, pain shot through my wrist, making me break out in a cold sweat.
From outside the door, I heard Mom speaking in a lowered voice, "I told you she'd come around. She didn't even talk back just now."
Dad gave a quiet hum. "Young people need to learn things the hard way."
Mom laughed. "Don't be so forceful with her next time. She responds better to kindness than pressure. Just make her think she's come to the decision herself."
I crouched on the floor and stopped trying to pick up the pencil.
After a while, I used my left hand to push it against the wall. Then I opened the drawer.
There were my ID card, bank cards, a few changes of clothes, and the old drawing Grandma had kept for me all these years—a blue roof and a big window.
I packed everything into my travel bag, one item at a time.
The only thing left was the house key. I held it for a few seconds. Then I put it back on the table.
The glass of milk outside my door was still warm. I picked up my bag and stepped over it.
The living room was dark.
Mom was washing dishes in the kitchen. When she heard me, she called through the doorway, "Your class starts at eight thirty tomorrow. Don't oversleep again."
I rested my hand on the doorknob. "Okay."
She gave a relieved little laugh. "That's more like it."
When I opened the door, the motion sensor light in the hallway flickered on.
Behind me, the door slowly swung shut. Not one person came out before the last sliver of light disappeared.
They still thought that this time, I'd finally learned my lesson.