Four Years As His Alibi

MotoNovel new Completed

We rented a beach house in the Outer Banks for the summer—just the four of us. On the very first afternoon, Drew handed the keys to the oceanfront master suite straight to Skylar, my so-called best friend. Before I could get a single word of protest past my teeth, Dean caught me by the elbow, laughing it off with that practiced, easygoing charm of his. "Come on, Lina. The room on the other side gets way better cross-breeze anyway. Let her have it." On our third morning, we chartered a boat out to the reef. The dive instructor told us one person had to stay on deck to watch our gear. Skylar complained about the glare, and Drew’s gaze shifted immediately to me. "You've never been a strong swimmer anyway, Lina," he said smoothly. "You stay." Right on cue, Dean unbuckled my life vest and slid it off my shoulders. "Listen to him, kiddo. The sun’s brutal today. Sit tight, and I’ll bring you back some conch shells." On the boat ride back, their heads were clustered together, scrolling through the camera roll with breathless laughter. In their underwater snapshots, the three of them were pressed shoulder-to-shoulder, their fingers curled together into playful hearts against the turquoise deep. Not a single person noticed that the frame was missing me. By the sixth evening, a vicious fever had settled into my bones. Shivering and desperate for ibuprofen, I walked past Skylar’s bedroom door and froze. Her voice drifted through the crack, sweet and petulant. "Every single time we want to mess around, you have to send Dean to drag her away. When are you actually going to tell her, Drew?" A heavy pause followed. Then Drew’s low, measured voice: "Didn't we already agree? We keep things exactly as they are." "Why?" "Because whenever it matters, she’s never in the room anyway." Skylar threw a quiet tantrum, and Drew spent the next ten minutes murmuring tender, patient apologies against her skin. Four years of college. Countless sudden errands. Dean abruptly dragging me out to s

Chapters (1)

Chapter 1

We rented a beach house in the Outer Banks for the summer—just the four of us. On the very first afternoon, Drew handed the keys to the oceanfront master suite straight to Skylar, my so-called best friend. Before I could get a single word of protest past my teeth, Dean caught me by the elbow, laughing it off with that practiced, easygoing charm of his. "Come on, Lina. The room on the other side gets way better cross-breeze anyway. Let her have it." On our third morning, we chartered a boat out to the reef. The dive instructor told us one person had to stay on deck to watch our gear. Skylar complained about the glare, and Drew’s gaze shifted immediately to me. "You've never been a strong swimmer anyway, Lina," he said smoothly. "You stay." Right on cue, Dean unbuckled my life vest and slid it off my shoulders. "Listen to him, kiddo. The sun’s brutal today. Sit tight, and I’ll bring you back some conch shells." On the boat ride back, their heads were clustered together, scrolling through the camera roll with breathless laughter. In their underwater snapshots, the three of them were pressed shoulder-to-shoulder, their fingers curled together into playful hearts against the turquoise deep. Not a single person noticed that the frame was missing me. By the sixth evening, a vicious fever had settled into my bones. Shivering and desperate for ibuprofen, I walked past Skylar’s bedroom door and froze. Her voice drifted through the crack, sweet and petulant. "Every single time we want to mess around, you have to send Dean to drag her away. When are you actually going to tell her, Drew?" A heavy pause followed. Then Drew’s low, measured voice: "Didn't we already agree? We keep things exactly as they are." "Why?" "Because whenever it matters, she’s never in the room anyway." Skylar threw a quiet tantrum, and Drew spent the next ten minutes murmuring tender, patient apologies against her skin. Four years of college. Countless sudden errands. Dean abruptly dragging me out to split late-night bar tabs, walk blocks for takeout, move his car, run to the campus library. The boy I had known since childhood, the one person I thought had my back, had spent four whole years playing lookout for my cheating boyfriend. Outside, the Atlantic broke against the shore—surging forward in violence, only to retreat in silence. I finally understood what the tide was trying to tell me. When it’s time to walk away, you don't wait for the sun to rise. 1 "Standing guard outside Skylar’s door at two in the morning?" Dean appeared at the top of the stairs, swinging a pair of condensation-slicked soda cans between his fingers. The fever hummed behind my eyes, making the hallway tilt. I dug my fingernails into my palms until the pain grounded me, then turned my head to look at him. Inside the room, the hushed voices cut out instantly. The door eased open an inch. Drew stood in the gap, wearing a soft gray T-shirt, his eyes flashing with a sudden, frantic flicker before smoothing into practiced concern. "What's going on out here? Lina? God, you look awful." Drew reached out, his knuckles brushing toward my forehead with the easy tenderness of an attentive partner. Behind his shoulder, Skylar peeked out, draped in a lavender silk robe. Her voice was pure syrup. "Lina? Why is everyone gathered outside my room? I thought someone was trying to break in." I pulled back from Drew’s touch. My throat felt like it had been scraped raw with broken glass. "I'm looking for the fever medicine." "The first-aid kit is downstairs under the coffee table," Dean said, stepping between us. He seized my wrist and pulled me toward the landing. His grip was entirely too hard, grinding the delicate bones together until they ached. Behind us, Drew exhaled softly. "Lina, go with Dean. Let him help you look. I’m heading to sleep." Skylar leaned lightly against the doorframe, offering a fragile smile. "Dean's always so thoughtful. Don't go wandering around in the dark, Lina." Dean hauled me down the stairs. My bare feet stumbled over the wooden treads. "Let go of me," I rasped. I wrenched my arm free and collapsed onto the living room sofa. Dean knelt by the coffee table, rummaged through the lower shelf, and tossed a blister pack of pills into my lap. "You're burning up. Take two and go to sleep. Stop making a scene." I stared down at the pills, my eyes burning. "Why was Drew in her room?" Dean’s hands stilled for a fraction of a second as he poured water from the pitcher. When he turned back, his face was an impenetrable wall. "The wall unit was dripping water on her floor. Drew went in to check the filter." "With the door shut? In the dead of night?" Dean slammed the glass down hard on the tabletop. Water slopped over the rim. "Lina, are you ever going to quit with the paranoia?" His voice cracked like a whip. "You've known Drew for four years. If he wanted to step out on you, you think he’d wait until this week? Skylar is your best friend. Why do you insist on turning everything into a catastrophe?" Looking at his righteous, exasperated face, a sudden wave of nausea rolled through my stomach. For four years, whenever Drew and Skylar slipped away, Dean would materialize out of thin air. He’d pull me toward late-night diners, drag me to save study carrels, badger me into grocery runs. I had thought he was my anchor. He was just clearing the room. "Dean," I said quietly, "do you really think I don't know?" Dean’s eyebrows pinched. A faint tremor disturbed his gaze before he hardened it again. "Know what? You're delirious. Stop talking nonsense." "The morning we went out to the reef," I whispered. "You guys had fun taking pictures underwater, didn't you?" "Lina—" "Drew said I was a liability in the water, and you took my life vest right off my back without hesitating. While the three of you were making hearts for the camera down below, my skin was peeling under the sun on that open deck." Dean grabbed a beach towel and tossed it over my bare shoulders, his tone dripping with irritation. "I did that for your own good. The UV index was through the roof, or did you forget your sun allergy? We took two quick photos and came right back up. Skylar posted a story—big deal. You're holding a grudge over an Instagram story? Get a grip, Lina. You sound like a bitter housewife." Footsteps padded softly down the stairs. Drew walked into the living room carrying a steaming ceramic mug. "Drink this, Lina. Hot honey and lemon. It'll help you sweat out the fever." He sat down beside me, the warmth of his body radiating against mine, his eyes swimming with an affection so thick it was suffocating. "I'm sorry about earlier. Skylar's AC was flooding her carpet, and I didn't realize you were feeling this bad. Don't be mad at Dean, okay? He's blunt, but he only snapped because he's worried sick about you." I stared down at the dark, swirling tea, my fingers icy. If I hadn't heard him say "she’s never in the room when it counts", I would have leaned against his chest and believed him. Just like I always had. "Drew," I said, "were you really just fixing an air conditioner?" Drew didn't flinch. He let out a helpless, affectionate chuckle and brushed a strand of hair from my cheek. "What else would I be doing? You silly girl. I only have eyes for you. You're jealous of Skylar? She's getting engaged next month, Lina. If she heard you talking like this, it would break her heart." From the kitchen counter, Dean let out a dry scoff. "Hear that? You bite the hand that feeds you." The rustle of silk announced Skylar’s arrival. She stepped into the soft glow of the kitchen, holding a tube of aloe vera. "Lina, you looked so red after the boat ride. I brought down some ointment. We came out here to relax, all four of us. Please don't take your stress out on Drew." They stood over me, closing the circle. Three voices, layered and synchronized, spinning an invisible web of gaslighting so dense that daylight couldn't pierce it. In their reality, I was the irrational, fragile intruder ruining their holiday. I shoved the mug away. Hot tea slopped over the ceramic rim, splashing across Drew’s bare wrists and soaking into the woven fibers of the sisal rug. Drew froze. Skylar let out a sharp gasp. "Lina! How could you do that? He made that for you!" Dean bolted upright, stepping toward the sofa with his finger pointed straight at my face. "Lina, what the hell is wrong with you?" 2 "Throwing a tantrum in the middle of the night—who are you performing for?" Dean loomed over the coffee table, his expression dark with fury. Drew caught Dean by the arm, playing the peacemaker. "Dean, stop. Back off. She's running a high fever; she's not thinking clearly." He pulled a handful of paper towels from the counter and knelt down on the damp rug, dabbing at the spilled tea. Skylar immediately dropped to her knees beside him. "Drew, let me. Your hand is already burned red. Don't touch it." Watching their shoulders brush together on the floor, my mind snapped back two years, to a brutal December afternoon during our sophomore year. Drew had slipped on black ice outside his dorm and broken his ankle. I spent three weeks handing out promotional flyers in below-freezing slush outside the commuter rail just to scrape together cash for his medical copays. My knuckles were cracked and bleeding from the frost. Then Dean had pulled up to the curb in his beat-up sedan, reached out, and dragged me inside. "Get in," he had insisted, "they’re doing a massive promotional giveaway across town, free grocery cards, we have to go right now." I told him I needed to finish my shift. I told him I needed the money. Dean didn't listen. He kept me trapped in that car, driving in endless circles across the city for three hours. By the time I finally reached the orthopedic ward, Drew’s hospital room door was ajar. Skylar was perched on the edge of his mattress, gently blowing on a spoon of chicken broth before feeding it to him. Drew had looked at her with an intensity so tender it made my throat tighten from the doorway. When the hinge squeaked, Skylar jumped up like a startled fawn. "Lina, please don't get the wrong idea. Dean called and said you were stuck at work, so I just came by to help." And Drew had reached for my freezing, chapped fingers, whispering, "Lina, Skylar’s just being sweet. Don't overthink it." God, I had been so blind. I had hugged her. I had thanked her with tears in my eyes, thinking I was the luckiest girl in the world to have a best friend who loved my boyfriend like a brother. The reality was that Dean had been staging their rendezvous since sophomore year. "Lina? Earth to Lina." Dean’s harsh voice broke through the memory. Drew was back on his feet, tossing the soggy paper towels into the trash. He reached out to pat my shoulder. "Take the pills, honey. I’ll carry you up to bed." I recoiled from his hand. I picked up the foil blister pack myself, punched two tablets through the silver backing, and swallowed them dry. The chalky bitterness dissolved on my tongue, burning all the way down into my empty stomach. "I can walk," I said. I braced my hands on the armrest and pushed myself up, my vision swimming. Skylar stepped closer, reaching out a manicured hand. "Let me help you up the stairs." A waft of cedarwood and smoked vanilla drifted from her skin. It was Drew’s signature cologne. The exact scent he kept in the console of his car. "Don't touch me," I said. Skylar’s arm froze mid-air. Her lower lip began to tremble, her eyes instantly pooling with tears. "Lina... do you hate me? If I'm making you this miserable, I'll pack my bags and book a flight home first thing in the morning." Drew’s jaw tightened as he looked at me. "Lina, she's only trying to be kind." "Kind?" A hollow laugh scraped past my lips. "Is that what you call staying in someone else's boyfriend's room until two in the morning?" Dean slammed his empty soda can down onto the counter. The aluminum crunched with a sharp, violent snap. "Watch your mouth, Lina!" he snarled. "We’ve known Skylar for four years. Who the hell do you think she is? Drew treats you like a queen, and you're manufacturing cheap drama out of thin air." Drew placed a calming hand on Dean’s shoulder, letting out a heavy sigh. "Dean, that's enough. She’s sick. When people are burning up, they say crazy things." He turned to me, his gaze coated in endless, patronizing patience. "Go to sleep, Lina. You'll feel different in the morning. I’m not angry with you." Look at him. So magnanimous. So endlessly forgiving. By reducing my devastation to a symptom of a fever, he painted me into a corner where every objection sounded like madness. He didn't even have to raise his voice to strip me of my sanity. Skylar sniffled, pulling the lapels of her robe together. "Lina, you're seeing ghosts. Drew and I have never crossed a line." "And the red mark on your collarbone?" I stared directly at the base of her throat. "Did the air conditioner do that, too?" Skylar’s hand flew to her neck, pulling the silk tightly over her skin, all color draining from her cheeks. Drew’s pupils contracted. Before the silence could settle, Dean lunged between us, blocking my view of her entirely. "They're sand-flea bites, you psycho! Look at my arm—I've got three of them right here!" He shoved his forearm into my face, pointing at several faded red bumps near his wrist. "You want to accuse me of sleeping with Drew, too?" Looking at Dean’s frantic, desperate defense of them, something cold and sharp severed inside my chest. "Dean," I whispered, "does lying for her come that naturally to you now?" He flinched. For a second, his eyes lost their arrogant edge, darting sideways before his defenses slammed back up. "I'm not lying for anyone! I'm calling out your bullshit! You're acting completely unhinged!" Drew stepped beside me, his voice dropping into that familiar, soothing cadence he used when he wanted me to drop an argument. "Come on, sweetheart. The sun’s going to be up soon. Go rest. We’re driving out to the lighthouse for sunrise, remember?" I looked at his smooth, handsome face, and a slow, quiet smile touched my lips. "You guys go," I said softly. "I'm not going." Drew’s brow twitched with faint irritation. "Don't pout, Lina." "I'm not pouting." I turned away from the three of them and began walking up the stairs, raising one hand in a dismissive wave behind my back. From the hallway below, Skylar’s muffled sobs rose up the stairwell. "Drew, this is all my fault. I shouldn't have come on this trip." "It's not your fault," Drew whispered, comforting her. "Don't cry." Dean’s voice followed, hard and dismissive. "Ignore her. She's spoiled. Once she sleeps it off and wakes up hungry, she’ll come crawling back down." I took the stairs one by one. With every step I climbed, their voices sounded clearer, knitting together like a tight-knit family closing ranks against an unwanted stranger. I reached the second-floor landing, walked into the cramped guest bedroom, and locked the door behind me. There was no ocean view here. The single window looked out onto a blank gray wall streaked with damp moss. On our first day, Dean had told me this room was cooler. He was right. Some rooms are cold, but nothing freezes you quite like the people you trusted with your life. I sat on the edge of the mattress, pulled out my phone, and opened my travel app. The earliest flight out of Norfolk was at nine o'clock tomorrow morning. Without pausing to breathe, I bought the ticket. The blue glow of the confirmation screen illuminated the dark room, reflecting the single, heavy tear that finally slipped down my cheek and shattered against the glass. A soft knock sounded at the door. "Lina? Open up, honey. I heated up some milk for you." 3 It was Drew. I stayed on the edge of the bed in the pitch-black room, motionless. "Lina? Are you asleep?" Two more soft taps. His tone remained perfectly calm, utterly patient. "I’m leaving the mug on the little side table out here. Drink it when you wake up, okay?" A brief pause. "Don't let your mind spin out. First thing tomorrow, I’ll drive into town and pick up those cinnamon rolls you love." His footsteps faded down the hall. I waited two minutes, then crept over and cracked the door open an inch. A steaming mug of milk rested on the wooden console table. Stuck to the ceramic curve was a yellow sticky note. Drew’s neat, architectural handwriting was unmistakable: "Stop overthinking everything. Get some rest. You're the only girl in the world for me." It was a beautiful note. It could have brought me to my knees. If I hadn't seen the hidden album on his phone last winter. It was Drew’s twenty-second birthday. He had passed out on our apartment sofa after too many IPAs. When I went to plug his phone into the wall charger, the screen had illuminated, resting on a locked vault app. The passcode was Skylar’s birthday. There were no scandalous photos in that folder. Just candid snapshots. Hundreds of them. Skylar chewing the end of a pen in the campus library. Skylar running across the quad on an October afternoon, her cardigan trailing behind her. Skylar laughing with a smear of strawberry gelato on her lip. The dates stretched from our freshman orientation straight through our senior year. Beneath each photo, Drew had written short, aching captions: "She took my breath away today." "I wish I could walk toward you in broad daylight." "Had to take Lina out to dinner again just to give us an excuse to see each other." I had sat on the rug that night, trembling violently, feeling the blood drain from my limbs before I quietly locked the screen and placed it back on the end table. The next morning, I tried to test the waters. "Drew, why does your phone have so many candid photos of Skylar?" Drew hadn't even blinked. He ruffled my hair and laughed. "Dean stored them there. You know Dean’s been in love with her forever—he was terrified his roommates would see them on his phone, so he asked me to hold them." And I had believed him. I had marched straight to Dean that afternoon. "Are you in love with Skylar?" Dean’s face had gone purple with rage. "Keep your nose out of my business! Drew doesn't know when to shut his damn mouth. Stop listening to his crap!" Now, the puzzle pieces snapped into place with terrifying clarity. Dean hadn't been angry that his secret was out. He was furious that Drew had used him as a human shield—and yet, Dean had swallowed the humiliation and played along anyway. What profound loyalty. To help Drew and Skylar conduct their little affair in the shadows, Dean had happily volunteered to be their pack mule, their chauffeur, their distraction. He had spent four years intercepting me every single time I was on the verge of catching them. I looked at the yellow sticky note, and a deep, visceral disgust rose in my throat. I ripped the paper from the mug, balled it up, and dumped the warm milk straight down the bathroom toilet. The flush roared through the small bathroom, swallowing the milk and the paper in a single violent vortex, washing it clean. Outside, the horizon was turning the pale, bruised gray of dawn. The dull thud of the ocean bled through the window frame, heavy and rhythmic. I pulled my duffel bag from the closet and began packing my clothes. There wasn't much to take. Most of what I had packed were loose linen dresses and oversized knit sweaters—things Drew insisted looked "effortless and pure." He always told me loud clothes were tacky. Meanwhile, Skylar’s wardrobe was an endless parade of backless halters and ribbed bodycon skirts. I tossed those modest linen dresses directly into the bedroom trash can. Then I unclasped the little woven shell bracelet from my wrist. Drew had bought it for twenty dollars from a boardwalk stall during our sophomore trip. He called it our promise band and made me swear I’d never take it off. Skylar’s neck, meanwhile, was graced with a five-hundred-dollar gold pendant Drew had skipped meals for two months to buy. I dropped the shell bracelet onto the nightstand. When I zipped the bag, it was startlingly light. Four years of devotion, and my entire presence in his life fit into a single duffel. Murmurs echoed from the bottom of the stairs. "Careful on the porch steps, Skylar. The dew is slick," Drew whispered. "Drew, shouldn't we at least wake Lina?" Skylar’s voice was a soft, manufactured whimper. "She’s going to be so lonely waking up here all by herself." Dean’s voice cut in instantly. "Leave her alone. Let her sleep. After the fit she threw last night, she’d only drag the whole mood down. We’ll grab breakfast on the way back from the lighthouse." "Come on," Drew said. "The car’s running." The heavy front door clicked shut. A moment later, an engine turned over in the gravel driveway, tires crunching as the car pulled away. They were gone. Off to chase the sunrise together. Leaving me alone with a raging fever in an empty beach house. Just like they had done a hundred times before. The three of them moving forward together, and me left behind to hold their ghosts. I shouldered my bag, pulled down the handle of my rolling suitcase, and walked out into the corridor. The open living area was a disaster. The remnants of last night's takeout littered the dining table. A plate sat on the counter with neatly stacked mango peels—Drew had peeled them for Skylar before our fight. Dean’s crushed soda cans littered the floor by the sink. This house had been the stage for their cozy little domestic theater, and the cemetery for my youth. I pulled out my phone, pulled up the property management app, and paid out my portion of the rental balance. Then I walked out the front door and closed it behind me. The morning sea breeze was sharp and damp, biting against the hot skin of my cheeks, shocking my senses into absolute, crystalline clarity. An Uber was waiting at the end of the paved lane. The driver tapped the steering wheel as I approached. "Airport, right?" "Yes," I said, sliding into the back. "Norfolk International." The car accelerated, and in the side mirror, the weathered gray cedar shakes of the rental house shrunk into a speck of driftwood before vanishing behind the dunes. I leaned my forehead against the cool glass, watching the scrub pines whip past. My screen lit up. A text from Drew: "The sunrise over the cape is breathtaking, Lina. Wish you were here to see it." A second later, an image loaded. Golden light spilling across the Atlantic. Skylar standing at the lighthouse railing, her hair lifted by the offshore wind. And at the far edge of the frame, a man’s hand rested possessively against the small of her back. Around that wrist was the matching woven red band Drew wore every single day. I stared at the screen. My heart didn't race. My stomach didn't drop. The anger was entirely gone, replaced by an arctic, immovable numbness. I didn't reply. The driver glanced in the rearview mirror. "Heading back home early, ma'am? Fight with your travel crew?" "No friends," I said, watching the highway markers blur. "Just heading home." "Shame. Gorgeous weather down here this week." "I've seen enough of it." At eight-ten, the car pulled up to the terminal curb. I stepped out onto the sidewalk, grabbed my bag from the trunk, and felt my phone begin to violently buzz in my pocket.

More MotoNovel Novels